Saturday, July 17, 2010

DNS root zone is now signed

The DNS root zone is now signed via DNSSEC. The idea behind DNSSEC is that the owner of a zone (roughly a domain) generates a public key and their DNS servers will digitally sign the records they serve up. Intermediate DNS servers will preserve those signatures, allowing querying machines to determine whether the records have been altered from what the authoritative nameserver sent. This makes it a lot harder to do a man-in-the-middle attack against DNS, hijacking a caching nameserver (say one belonging to an ISP) in order to re-route traffic to an attacker's servers. Not impossible, but it's a lot more involved. That's because the public key needed to verify a signature is returned from the zone above the signed zone and is signed by that zone, eg. the public key for silverglass.org's records is returned from the .org zone's server and the key for the .org zone is returned by the root nameservers. So for an attacker to forge silverglass.org records, he has to subvert the entire chain back to the root. Each verifying machine has the single key for the root zone pre-loaded (and presumably verified out-of-band to make sure it's valid), so it's infeasible to fake signatures on records for the TLDs (eg. .com, .org, .us). If I can control the records returned for .org queries I can substitute my key for silverglass.org's, allowing me to forge signatures on silverglass.org records. But since I can't substitute my key for the root key I can't fake signatures of the .org records containing the silverglass.org key, and any verifying server will detect my forgery.

That's great for security, but it poses a problem for some (IMO unethical) ISPs and DNS providers like Network Solutions. That's because they've been playing a game: when someone asks for a domain that doesn't exist, instead of returning NXDOMAIN (non-existent domain) for the query they've returned a valid result for the name pointing at their servers which serve up advertising, search results and the like. Essentially they take ownership of every single invalid domain and slap their advertisements on it. But as soon as downstream DNS servers (eg. the ones in every home router) start verifying DNSSEC signatures, the gravy train ends because those ISPs and DNS providers have no way of forging valid signatures. The only exception is that the registry operator can forge results for completely unowned domains within it's scope, and the most common DNS software around has a flag to stop that (TLD servers are expected to only delegate to 2LD servers, they should never return actual results so any results they try to return must be faked and should be treated as NXDOMAIN).

No comments: